Mary played piano at the small Baptist church in town. I played bass and was the lead singer in a local rock band. She was sixteen, and I was eighteen. It was Saturday evening, and the weather was cool for June, so I had my windows down as I was cruising in my GTO. Saturday in a small town is when all the guys with cars cruise through the small downtown area and past McDonald’s and DQ, trying to pick up chicks.

As I was passing the church, I heard the piano playing. Whoever was playing was playing Cat Stevens’ music and not hymns. I pulled into the parking lot and slipped in the side door. I noticed this beautiful angel with red hair playing away.

Her hair was long, braided pigtails with strands of hair hanging down in front on both sides. I leaned against the wall, watching her play song after song effortlessly, without sheet music.

My attention went elsewhere when I heard a commotion in the church office. I peeked in and there was a buxom red-haired lady with her tits out and her dress pulled over her ass. Her panties were around her ankles, and she was grunting and moaning. A large black man was roughly fucking her from behind and spanking her ass. His muscular ass was flexing as he thrust into her. His dark black cock had to be ten inches long and as thick as her wrist.

“I’m cumming, you white bitch. Take my cock and feel my seed fill you up,” the man shouted.

“God, yes! I love your black cock. Fuck my married pussy hard. Argh!” She came hard. She glanced over her shoulder and saw me standing there. I quickly ducked away.

I went up to the girl at the piano. She stopped playing and said, “Oh my God! You are Mac Johnson from my school. What are you doing in here?” she excitedly said.

“I heard your beautiful playing, so I came in here to hear more, and I found a beautiful redhead that stunned all my senses. What is your name?” I replied.

“I’m Mary. I’m just a sophomore, but I love your band,” she replied.

We talked awhile, then I asked if she wanted to go get a burger. We went outside and climbed into my Red 1964 Pontiac GTO. Mary was so excited. She leaned against the passenger door and sat cross-legged. She talked so fast that I could barely understand her.

She was wearing a white sweater over a pink top. Her pleated skirt was a plaid red and green. She was wearing short, white socks with lace at the tops. Her shoes were those black and white saddle oxfords. Sitting cross-legged, I could see her white panties and her milky white thighs.

She looked so sweet and innocent. We parked in the back of the parking lot at DQ. We both just ordered a shake and some fries.

We were sitting there enjoying ourselves when she reached over and unzipped my pants. She pulled out my flaccid cock and stared at it with hunger. She used two fingers and her thumb to jerk me off. My cock grew hard in her hand to seven inches. She grasped the base with her entire hand and placed her mouth over the head. Her tongue twirled around the sensitive rim. She swallowed my cock until her lips hit her hand. Her head bobbed as she jerked my cock with her hand. She was moaning as she gave me an incredible blow job. I gently stroked her hair as her dark blue eyes locked onto my crystal blue eyes.

I grunted, and I filled her mouth with my salty gift. She swallowed it all and kept sucking until my cock was clean. “That was incredible, Mary,” I blurted. We kissed each other for a minute, then she took off her sweater. Her sheer pink top had string straps, and I could see her dark nipples through the fabric.

I pulled her straps off her shoulders and lowered her top. She had tiny breasts with small areolas. I sucked each breast as she cradled my head. I pulled her panties to the side and inserted two fingers into her pussy. She was soaking wet. I plunged my fingers in and out and pushed against her G-spot. She bit my ear as she climaxed. Her pussy tightened around my fingers and her fluids filled my hand.

I put her panties back into place and licked my hand and sucked my fingers. As Mary put her tits away and put her sweater back on, she said, “You’d better take me home now or my dad will get really mad.” She gave me directions to her house. It was the small house behind the church. I realized the house was where the preacher lived. “Come to supper tomorrow before evening service. Ask my parents’ permission if you want to date me. You want to date me, don’t ya?”

“Yes, of course,” I stammered. She kissed me on the cheek and skipped into the house. I sat there dazed for a few minutes, just staring into the sky.

I arrived at Mary’s house at five o’clock. She and her father greeted me at the door. He was a short, pudgy man with a grumpy face. “Mac, this is my father, the Reverend. Dad, this is Mac, my new boyfriend,” she introduced.

His face turned red at the boyfriend comment. “We will see about that,” he grumped. We went into the living room. Just then, her mother came around the corner carrying a plate of roast beef and mashed potatoes. She nearly dropped them when she saw me. Her mother was the big-tittied redhead getting fucked from behind with that enormous black cock. She stuttered, “Hi Mac, it’s nice to meet you.”

We sat at the table and ate and talked. Her dad was totally against me dating his daughter, stating reasons like my age, my band, my car, my lack of a job, and that my dad was a lowly car mechanic. Mary was sobbing and pleading.

I kept my cool and said, “Why don’t we let the Mrs. decide if I can date her daughter or not?”

The preacher smiled, as he knew his wife was more strict with Mary than he was. I stared defiantly at Mary’s mom. She stared back at me with a defeated look on her face and said, “I see nothing wrong with this young man dating our daughter, just as long as he respects her and gets her home by curfew.”

Smiling at the preacher, I said, “Thank you, ma’am. You’ve made your daughter very happy.”

The preacher stormed off. “I have a sermon to prepare for!”

Mary was wearing a flowered sundress with some sandals and a plastic hair band when we got in my car after supper. “Go park behind the dumpster at the church,” Mary ordered.

It was thirty minutes before Mary had to play the piano for Sunday evening church service. She pulled her top down, flaunting her small, perfect titties. She hiked up her dress to her waist and pushed her white panties down and off. She displayed a neatly trimmed, triangular red bush and red-fuzz-covered labia. “Fuck me quick,” she blurted. She spread her legs as she lay back on the front bench seat.

I could see her wet, pink entrance between her pink butterfly-shaped lips. I pushed my jeans and boxers down to my knees and crawled between her legs. My mushroom head spread her inner folds further apart. Mary moaned as my cock slipped inside her. She was wet and ready. She pushed her feet on the ceiling of my car. I was deep inside her and she was thrashing her hips up and down, fucking my cock.

Mary had experience. She has obviously fucked many times before me. I pushed deep inside her tight pussy. Her eyes widened, and her breathing hastened as I felt her walls tighten around my shaft. She let out a little squeaking noise as she felt my sperm spread inside her. I didn’t know if she was using protection or not.

“That was a fabulous fucking. Hand me my panties,” she requested. She pulled her panties on, thus locking in my cum deposit. She straightened out her dress and put her tits back in place. I drove to the front of the church and parked. We walked in the front doors holding hands. I sat in the back row as she walked to the piano and plopped down on the piano bench.

She played beautiful hymns as my cum saturated her panties.

She took me around to meet her friends at school on Monday. They all giggled and whispered to Mary. My friends couldn’t believe that I was dating a lowly sophomore. I just said she was cute, and we had fun together.

On Wednesday, Mary and I were sitting on her couch. I had just fucked her from behind in the backyard. Her mom said, “Mary, you need to get to the church and help your dad pick out new music for Easter Sunday.”

“Yes, ma’am. “Mac and I will head over,” she replied.

“No, I need Mac to help me with a few chores before church,” she responded.

Once Mary left, her mom turned to me. “You can call me Janet. I saw you two fucking outside. You need to be more careful. You can fuck in Mary’s bedroom when I’m home,” Janet explained. “You know that the preacher and I are not Mary’s birth parents, right?”

“No, Janet, I didn’t know that,” I answered.

“She is my husband’s sister’s daughter. She passed away during childbirth at only seventeen years old. So we adopted Mary,” she explained. “She is a handful. She acts out because the Reverend is too strict. I act out, too, as you witnessed. The Reverend doesn't care for sex, and when we have sex, it’s about once a month. It’s over in less than five minutes when he cums, then rolls off me. I never get to cum, plus he has a small cock.”

She pulled down her dress, and it fell to the floor. She was wearing a bright red push-up bra with matching French-cut panties. Her large, pink areolas stuck out over the top of the bra. Janet had hunger in her eyes. She tweaked the clasps on the front of the bra, and it fell away. The close-up view revealed that her large, round breasts were silicone-filled.

Janet pulled my stiff cock out of my pants and dropped to her knees. “Mmm! I smell pussy on your cock,” she panted. She took my entire cock into her mouth. I massaged her big boobs. I roughly fucked her face. She sucked very well, but not as good as her daughter. My cum exploded in her mouth, making her cough and gag. Cream dripped down her chin and onto her boobs.

I spun her around and bent her over the couch. I noticed the caning scars on her back. I ran my fingers over the scars and kissed them. I pulled her panties down to her knees. She looked over her shoulder with her big green eyes and pleaded, “spank me and fuck my ass. I’ve been naughty and need to be punished.”

I slapped her juicy ass hard repeatedly. She whimpered and danced in place. I spanked until she hollered, “Enough, Mac, that’s enough.” Her mascara was running down her face. “Fuck my raw ass!”

I pushed my mushroom head into her starfish. She squealed with delight. My cock easily slipped in and out of her colon. Her pussy was dripping heavily on the floor. Since I had just come into her mouth, it took twenty minutes to flood her with my cream.

She rolled over and sat with her legs spread wide on the couch. Her red pubic hair was long and wild. I pushed my face through the thick jungle and found her wet entrance with my tongue. Janet pulled my hair and pushed me hard into her cunt. I lapped up her juices and fucked her with my tongue. Her creamy fluid poured out onto my mouth as she screamed.

I wiped my pussy juice cover face onto her fake titties. My cock entered her sloppy cunt. She was loose around my cock. I felt her inner walls adjusting and tightening around my shaft. Janet dug her heels into my ass. She was having multiple orgasms. I came for a third time, a fourth time if you count the one I dumped into her daughter.

She pulled her panties up, also capturing my cum in her cunt. I took a quick shower, but she went to church smelling of sex.

She stood next to her husband on the altar, and he could smell the sex scent on her. She knew she was getting the cane that night. She was excited that she was going to be caned.

She is the only one who knows his secrets. Especially the one where he licked the cum of her lover out of her pussy. He never knew whose cum it was.

Mary and I dated until I graduated. On graduation night, I rented a hotel room. Mary wore a long, flowing skirt and a tube top. The tube top came off first. I sucked her small nipples and kissed her beautiful mouth. Mary pulled down the zipper on her skirt and let it fall to the floor. She wore pink cotton panties.

My shirt came off next, then my jeans. Only my boxers remained. We stood facing each other. We planned this night for a while. This was going to be our last night together. In two days, I was going away as I had enlisted in the Army. We were to make love tonight, along with two other objectives.

First, she was going to let me take her anal cherry. Second, we were going to pick out her new boyfriend for the upcoming year.

Mary knelt in front of me and pulled down my boxers. She put her lips over my head and pushed her mouth down my shaft. She came off my cock and smacked her lips. “You fucked Janet today, didn’t you?” She Inquired. Mary could taste Janet’s pussy juice on my cock. I had indeed fucked Janet from behind in the bathroom right before graduation.

“You know I did. Now suck my cock,” was my reply. Mary laughed and plunged down on my cock and playfully scraped her teeth down the shaft. Her lips came to rest in my pubes. Mary had me cumming in minutes.

I pulled her panties down and ran my fingers through her red triangle. She leaned back on the bed and put her feet on my shoulders. My tongue explored her fuzzy outer folds before splitting her lips and delving into her pink entrance. Mary came, and I lapped up her nectar. I sucked her sensitive clitoris until she came again.

I rubbed her nipples as we passionately kissed. My cock fully pushed into her cunt. Mary let out a loud grunt. We made slow love for about twenty minutes. She came hard, but I did not. I pulled out, as I did not want my cum in her pussy tonight.

Mary stood up and kissed me, then she bent over the bed and with her two hands spread her ass cheeks. I poured lube onto her starfish and onto my cock. I lubricated my cock thoroughly. Mary panted, saying, “Fuck my ass, boy.”

The tip of my cock easily pushed in until it hit her sphincter ring. She jumped as it was painful. I waited a moment and pushed my cock further in. Her anus stretched around my cock. Mary grunted in pain as I opened up her ass. My balls rested on her labia. I was fully in, as Mary could hardly catch her breath.

I slowly pumped my cock into her colon. She was tight. It was a weirdly smooth sensation around my shaft. I fucked her ass for a few minutes as Mary was now adding moans of pleasure to her grunts of pain. My cum erupted in her ass. Mary was relieved that the ass fucking was over.

Mary stayed naked but got under the covers. I was fully dressed when a knock came on the door at ten o’clock. As the door opened, three new seniors came in.

John, and tall white football player, was first in the door. Manny, a black, muscular track star, came in next. Billy, a handsome book nerd, came in last.

These were the three boys that Mary had picked to try out for her new boyfriend. Mary threw back the covers and spread her legs. “Who’s first?” Mary asked.

Manny pushed his way to the front and pulled out his cock. It was long and skinny. Mary sucked his cock for a few minutes and then had him fuck her missionary. Although Mary orgasmed, she felt unimpressed.

John had a huge, fat cock. He fucked Mary wildly. He had no style, though Mary looked at how he stretched her pussy. He came and pulled out. Mary wasn’t even close to coming.

Billy kissed Mary and played tongue twister with her. He gently sucked her little titties and slowly fingered her to climax. He ate her pussy, cleaning the other boys’ cum out. Mary grabbed his six-inch cock and stroked it. She liked the feel of his hard, smooth shaft. He lay on his back and had Mary sink her pussy down on his cock. Her eyes rolled up in her head. She had found the one. The book nerd knew how to fuck and to treat Mary with respect. Mary came multiple times and Billy unloaded an ungodly amount of creamy cum into Mary’s cunt.

The other two boys and I left them to get to know each other better. I went to Mary’s house and fucked Janet while her husband watched.